I had intended to post a long, involved entry on the All-Star Game, but that did not materialize because despite the highlight of Andruw going deep on Kenny Rogers, the game was predictably dull and contrived, and before long I realized that anything I were to write about it would be equally so.
All I have is this one thought regarding the midseason classic: tying the outcome of an exhibition game to home-field advantage in the World Series is inappropriate and a bit bizarre, and does not appear to provide any additional motivation to the players, who are solely responsible for determining the level of play. Take John Smoltz, for example. He gave up a home run in his inning of work and took the loss for it; but he told reporters afterward that he was not concerned about his performance, and was simply pleased to have played an All-Star Game in his home state. Now, what does it say about the effectiveness of the home-field advantage in motivating players if it does not motivate a fierce a competitor as John Smoltz?
If MLB wants the make the All-Star Game more competitive by making it "count," they should simply make the stats count by figuring them into the statistical totals for the regular season. I guarantee that Smoltz would have been more concerned about his All-Star performance if it had resulted in another tally mark in the L column of his season numbers and an increase in his season ERA. I'm not trying to trash Smoltz; that is simply the reality of the situation. As players on a contender for postseason play, Smoltz and Andruw at least had a small stake in the game's outcome; but what about Jason Bay? Mike Sweeney? Shea Hillenbrand? All they have besides the thrill, the prestige, the bonus (wait a minute .. shouldn't that be enough?) is the possible added incentive of having their performance in the game count in their season totals. That's something they will care about -- especially if they are in a contract or arbitration year. It would have to beat the hell out of tying the game's outcome to something so incongruous.
Posted by MHB
at 7:46 AM EDT
Updated: Saturday, 16 July 2005 3:44 PM EDT